Judge unmoved by political pressure

Limerick District Court Judge Eugene O'Kelly
Limerick District Court Judge Eugene O’Kelly

By KATHRYN HAYES

[email protected]

A JUDGE who threatened to jail two graffiti artists whoย defaced properties in Limerick city, including the Frank McCourt museum has insisted his court will not be โ€œpilloriedโ€ or influenced by political comment.

Judge Eugene Oโ€™Kelly made his remarks at Limerick District Court where he previously warned two teenagers theyย faced up to five months in prison unless they took part in a โ‚ฌ4,500 clean up operation at the museum.

Advertisement

Jonathan Noonan (19) of Upper Cecil Street, Limerick and Ruairi Fogarty (19) of Drominbeg Rhebogue, Limerick are charged with defacing a number of properties in Limerick including the Frank McCourt Museum which depicts the early life of the family of the Pulitzer prize-winning novelist.

After entering guilty pleas, both men gave an undertaking to clean up the historic building ahead of international celebrations which took place at the museum recently to mark the Irish premiere of โ€˜Angelas Ashes, A Musicalโ€™.

Speaking at one these functions Labour Councillor Tom Shortt who was deputising as Mayor called on Una Heaton the Directorย of the Frank McCourt museum to adopt the โ€˜compassionateโ€™ nature of the famous author when she presented a progress report to court on the graffiti artists ordered to clean up her building.

โ€œI hope that Unaโ€™s further intervention in this case will be in the spirit of Frank McCourt,โ€ he said, adding that her report โ€œwill have a huge bearing on whether they go to prison or not.โ€

When the case was called last Wednesday Judge Oโ€™Kelly said it was notย the function of the court to get involved in the public life of Limerick city but said he regretted Ms Heaton was subjected to remarks from people โ€œwho were not present in courtโ€.

Ms Heaton he continued did not criminalise the young men adding, โ€œtheir own actions is what criminalised themโ€.

Praising the director of the Frank McCourt museum for her courage when she previously gave evidence to the court about the damage caused, he said he welcomed her intervention which he said, offered a practical solution concerning the participation in the clean up operation, which meant the young men could avoid a custodial sentence.

Judge Oโ€™Kelly insisted Ms Heaton and his court would not be pilloried by others who โ€œhold a different view of matters and who were not present in courtโ€.

He said the matter was sub judice and should not be the subject of comment by politicians adding:

โ€œThis court is not going to be influenced by remarks made by politicians or anyone else.โ€

Judge Oโ€™Kelly said he was satisfied the progress reports were positive and adjourned the case until October 2 next.

 

Advertisement